Data hosting in Switzerland or France: which should you choose for your app?
Back to the blog
Business

Data hosting in Switzerland or France: which should you choose for your app?

Jérémy
Jérémy
Founder & CTO
24 October 20268 min read

Host your app's data in Switzerland or in France? What the nLPD and the GDPR say, the CLOUD Act, SecNumCloud and the cases where the choice matters.

For an SME in Geneva or Annecy, hosting its application's data in Switzerland or in France is, in the vast majority of cases, equally safe from a legal point of view. Switzerland recognises France as a country that properly protects data, and the European Union recognises Switzerland in the same way. The real issue is therefore not the border between the two countries. It is the nationality of your hosting provider, the sensitivity of the data you process and what your clients expect of you.

Here is how to think it through, with the rules that apply on each side and the questions to ask before signing with a provider.

What does Swiss law say about hosting data abroad?

The new Federal Act on Data Protection, often called the nLPD (nFADP in English), came into force on 1 September 2023 together with its ordinance, the OPDo. It does not require data to be hosted in Switzerland. It does, however, regulate disclosure abroad: a company may send personal data to another country if the Federal Council considers that this country provides adequate protection.

The list of these countries is set out in the annex to the OPDo. France is on it, like the other European Union member states. The Federal Data Protection and Information Commissioner points this out on its page on disclosure of data abroad: to a country on the list, no additional safeguards are needed. To a country not on the list, contractual clauses are required, for example the standard clauses recognised by the Commissioner.

In practical terms, a Geneva fiduciary firm can entrust its data to a hosting provider based in Strasbourg or Roubaix without any particular formality under the nLPD. It remains responsible for what its provider does, but the country of storage is not a problem in itself.

And on the French side, does the GDPR allow hosting in Switzerland?

Yes. Switzerland has benefited from a European Union adequacy decision since 2000. The European Commission confirmed it on 15 January 2024 in its report on existing adequacy decisions. Data can therefore flow from France to Switzerland without specific clauses, as between two EU countries.

An SME in Annecy working with clients on both sides of the border can therefore choose a data centre in Geneva or Lyon based on criteria other than data protection law.

Why does the hosting provider's nationality matter more than the country?

Because a server located in Europe does not necessarily escape foreign laws. The US CLOUD Act, adopted in 2018, allows the United States authorities to require a provider subject to US law to hand over the data it controls, including when that data is stored outside the United States. A European company renting servers in Frankfurt from an American cloud giant therefore remains exposed to this kind of request.

The CNIL (the French data protection authority) has taken a position on this point in an article on the risks of foreign authorities accessing data hosted in the cloud. It considers this risk generally limited for non-sensitive data, since the United States has been considered adequate since 10 July 2023 for companies that have joined the Data Privacy Framework. For the most sensitive data, such as large health databases, data relating to offences or data concerning minors, it recommends a provider subject exclusively to European law, for example one qualified SecNumCloud.

Switzerland applies a similar logic: since 15 September 2024, the United States has only been on its list for organisations certified under the Swiss-US Data Privacy Framework.

Aerial view of a data centre with a grey roof, surrounded by fields and forests

Photo: Geoffrey Moffett on Unsplash

Which hosting providers should you choose in Switzerland and France?

Infomaniak and Exoscale: what do the Swiss hosting providers offer?

Infomaniak is a company founded in Geneva in 1994. It undertakes to store its customers' data only in its own data centres in Switzerland, including the one in Plan-les-Ouates, which recovers its heat for the Geneva district heating network. For an SME that wants a local contact and a complete offering, from web hosting to cloud servers, it is often the first option considered.

Exoscale is aimed more at technical teams. Its cloud has two zones in Switzerland, in Geneva and Zurich, and other zones in Europe, notably in Vienna, Frankfurt and Munich. It makes it possible to keep an application in Switzerland while adding a backup copy in another European country if needed.

SecNumCloud: what is this French qualification for?

SecNumCloud is a qualification issued by ANSSI, the French cybersecurity agency. It covers trusted cloud offerings capable of protecting sensitive data against cyberattacks and against the application of extraterritorial laws. Among other things, it requires a head office in the European Union and limits the share held by non-European shareholders.

Two points avoid misunderstandings. The qualification applies to a specific offering, not to an entire hosting provider: at OVHcloud, for example, only certain offerings are qualified. Whether you are looking at OVHcloud, Scaleway or another player, check that the exact offering is listed in the ANSSI catalogue. Secondly, as ANSSI points out, the qualification does not guarantee the security of the service you install on it. A poorly protected application remains vulnerable on a qualified infrastructure.

For most SMEs, SecNumCloud is not mandatory. It becomes a real criterion if you process highly sensitive data or if a public-sector client requires it in its specifications.

Do latency and cost really change the choice?

For an application used in the Geneva area, the difference in latency between a server in Geneva and a server in eastern France is generally too small to be noticed by a user viewing a record or filling in a form. It can matter for highly interactive uses, such as real-time synchronisation between several workstations. In that case, a test from your users' premises is worth more than a theoretical figure.

On cost, compare equivalent offerings rather than countries. Swiss prices are invoiced in CHF, French prices in euros, and the difference depends mainly on the level of service: backups, support, availability commitment. The heaviest item is often the time spent installing and maintaining the server, not renting the machine.

When does the choice between Switzerland and France matter for an SME in Geneva or Annecy?

In most projects, both options are suitable. The choice becomes decisive in a few situations we come across regularly.

  • Your clients or partners require it by contract. International organisations or NGOs in Geneva often ask for hosting in Switzerland, whatever the applicable law.
  • You process sensitive data: health, data on minors, legal or financial files. The hosting provider must then fall exclusively under Swiss or European law, and the contract must specify where backups are stored.
  • You are responding to a public tender in France that requires a SecNumCloud-qualified offering.

Good news for small organisations: the OPDo exempts companies with fewer than 250 employees from keeping a record of processing activities, unless they process sensitive data on a large scale or carry out high-risk profiling. Data protection still applies, but the paperwork is lighter.

How does METEORA host its clients' applications?

We host our clients' projects on our own servers in Switzerland and France, administered with Coolify, our deployment tool, without going through an American cloud. The country is chosen project by project: in Switzerland when the client falls under the nLPD or its partners require it, in France when it works mainly with the European Union.

If you are preparing an application and are unsure, our article on the cost of a mobile app in Switzerland in CHF helps frame the overall budget, and you can estimate your project's budget with our calculator. For an internal tool, the page on custom software for SMEs details how we work. Our web and mobile development agency in Geneva also supports companies in the region with these hosting choices, from the scoping stage.

Don't know where your data is stored today? Ask your current provider. If they take a long time to answer, that already tells you something.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal for a Swiss company to host its data in France?

Yes. France is on the list of countries recognised by Switzerland as providing adequate data protection, in the annex to the OPDo (the Data Protection Ordinance). Data can be hosted there without additional safeguards, with the company remaining responsible for its provider.

Can a French company host its data in Switzerland?

Yes. Switzerland has benefited from a European Union adequacy decision since 2000, confirmed by the European Commission on 15 January 2024. Data flows between France and Switzerland as it does between two EU countries.

Does a server in Europe protect against the CLOUD Act?

Not necessarily. The CLOUD Act allows US authorities to request data from a provider subject to US law, even if it is stored in Europe. For sensitive data, the CNIL recommends a provider subject exclusively to European law.

Is SecNumCloud mandatory for an SME?

No, in most cases. This ANSSI qualification becomes useful for highly sensitive data or when a public-sector client requires it. It applies to a specific offering, so you need to check the exact offering in the ANSSI catalogue.

Where does METEORA host its clients' applications?

On its own servers in Switzerland and France, administered with Coolify, without any American cloud. The country is chosen according to each client's obligations and expectations.

HostingData protectionnLPDGDPRSecNumCloudSME

How much would your project cost?

Project type, features, timeline: a costed estimate in two minutes, with no commitment.

Estimate my budget

Where should your app's data be hosted?

From Rumilly, 45 minutes from Geneva, we help you choose between Switzerland and France based on your data and your clients, then we host and maintain your application.